Crush on This: Dead Poets, Victorian Heroines, and One Very Clever Detective: A Spooky Season Classic Adaptations Roundup

Crushed on by Christy Jane, on October 23, 2026, in Crush on This, New Releases / 0 Comments

Crush on This: Dead Poets, Victorian Heroines, and One Very Clever Detective: A Spooky Season Classic Adaptations Roundup

October is the perfect time to revisit the stories that have haunted literature for centuries. and the YA authors who have taken those stories apart and rebuilt them into something new. The best ones use familiar bones to lay plainly something the original couldn’t (or wouldn’t). Here’s a roundup of classic adaptations worth picking up this spooky season!

Crush on This: Dead Poets, Victorian Heroines, and One Very Clever Detective: A Spooky Season Classic Adaptations Roundup

The Forgotten Lore (Ellen Poe #1)

by Diana Peterfreund
Published by: Running Press Kids
on April 7, 2026
Bookshop
Goodreads

The first book in an exciting YA series about a teen girl, descended from Edgar Allan Poe, who must navigate the haunting legacy of her ancestor while learning to harness her own strength and intelligence, especially as she begins to commune with the dead.

A Junior Library Guild Gold Standard Selection!
A Kids' Indie Next List Pick!

What happens when your tell-tale nightmares turn into reality and the ghost of Edgar Allan Poe won't seem to let you alone? For as long as she can remember, sixteen-year-old Ellen Poe's family has claimed to be long-lost descendants of Edgar Allan Poe. But when she moves in with her aunt in a Poe-themed B&B, the nightmares that have always haunted her begin bleeding into Ellen’s waking hours. When she stumbles upon a journal in the house, none other than Edgar Allan Poe himself begins visiting her. Has the journal somehow released his ghost? And what does he want with Ellen? Through secret messages in his writings, she learns that the two share the same psychic ability to interact with spirits—which is what ultimately drove him mad.

This thrilling series for young adult readers follows Ellen on her quest to learn more about her abilities, the afterlife, and the clues Poe has left for her (ciphers and cryptograms galore), in an effort to not suffer his same fate.

Start Here: Ellen Poe

Diana Peterfreund’s Ellen Poe: The Forgotten Lore and Ellen Poe for Evermore reimagine Edgar Allan Poe as a teenage girl detective in 19th-century Baltimore. Ellen is Poe’s fictional niece, solving gothic mysteries while navigating the same dark, atmospheric world her uncle made famous. These books are exactly what the season calls for: moody, clever, and deeply in love with their source material. If you’ve ever wanted more from Poe’s world, Ellen delivers.

The Sherlock Files

Brittany Cavallaro’s Charlotte Holmes series (A Study in Charlotte, The Last of August, The Case for Jamie, and A Question of Holmes) is one of the best YA series of the last decade. Charlotte is a descendant of Sherlock Holmes, Jamie Watson is a descendant of the original Watson, and the two are thrown together at a New England boarding school when a classmate is murdered and they’re the prime suspects. Brittany keeps everything that makes Holmes compelling and builds something genuinely her own on top of it.

Classic Reimaginings Worth Knowing

The Guinevere Deception by Kiersten White takes the Arthurian legend and centers Guinevere not as a tragic love interest but as an active agent with her own magic and her own secrets. Kiersten’s version of Camelot is darker and more complicated than the one you might be familiar with!

The Dark Descent of Elizabeth Frankenstein, also by Kiersten White, retells Frankenstein from Elizabeth’s point of view, and in doing so, completely reframes what the novel is about. Elizabeth is no passive figure waiting to be rescued. She’s been surviving Victor Frankenstein her entire life, and her story is one of survival, manipulation, and the cost of loving someone who refuses to see you clearly.

These Hollow Vows by Beth Revis takes A Midsummer Night’s Dream into darker fae territory. The magic is real, the stakes are higher, and the romance is thornier than Shakespeare let on.

Reader, I Murdered Him by Betsy Cornwell picks up Jane Eyre after the fire at Thornfield and asks what Jane might do if she were angrier, and less forgiving. It’s a revenge novel and a love story and a gothic mystery, and it commits fully to every one of those things.

The Remix Shelf

This is where things get interesting. Macmillan has an entire shelf of remixed classics, shifting a classic text, queering it, centering a different character, or transplanting it somewhere new.

Teach the Torches to Burn by Caleb Roehrig imagines a secret romance between Romeo and Rosaline’s brother during the events of Romeo and Juliet. The tragedy is still there, but so is the passion. My Dear Henry by Kalynn Bayron is a Jekyll and Hyde remix told from Henry Jekyll’s perspective, with a queer love story woven through the horror of what Hyde becomes. This Wretched Beauty by Elle Grenier takes The Picture of Dorian Gray and reimagines Dorian as a girl in 1920s Paris. The decadence, the vanity, and the creeping moral rot are all still present, just refracted through a world that had its own particular rules about women and beauty and sin. Most Ardently by Gabe Cole Novoa reimagines Pride and Prejudice with Darcy as a trans man navigating Regency-era society. The social stakes of the original, what women could and couldn’t own, choose, or say, become even higher when Darcy has his own reasons for keeping secrets. Self Made Boys by AM McLemore transplants The Great Gatsby to a 1920s Latino community in New York, with Nick and Gatsby both reimagined as queer Latinx men. AM’s prose is lush and strange in the best way, and this version of the story hits differently when it’s grounded in a community the original erased entirely.

What classic stories would you want to see get the YA remix treatment? Drop them in the comments…we’re always looking for the next one.

Tags: , ,


Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.